well i guess if you need to rely on your car and your car is having problems it would make sense to trade it in while you can. better than being stuck with a broken car halfway across the country on a road trip.
Bluwoody, just wondering why you didn't try another ATS? Chances are the second one would have been okay. Did they give you that option? I sure love mine.
yeah usually getting another ATS from a different production time frame would be better as the same issues might not be present, finding that out is probably the best thing to do before buying a new ATS
Yes I would buy another. Its now about 1.5 years old with 22k on the ticker and no real problems. My only issue is I have the optional wheels which leave you with anti pot hole tires (35 series), have bent two of them so far but otherwise the car is good. Yes CUE is slower than I would like but you get use to it and I understand the new one is much better. Mileage is average around 24 with the 2.0 and AWD.